A story last week, suggested disgraced former NRL player Tim Simona was on his way back into NRL circles after a meeting with Panthers boss Phil Gould.
The former Tiger was exiled from the game after over fraud, betting, and drugs offences, but is now seeking to rejoin an NRL club in a welfare officer role.
During a segment on Triple M Sunday NRL, the panel of Gordie Tallis, Paul Kent, Ben Ikin and Anthony Maroon were divided over Simon'a potential return.
LISTEN HERE: