The David Mackay incident has divided the football world this week, the Midweek Rub team dissected his case in preparation for Thursday's tribunal hearing.
The Crows midfielder was sent straight to the tribunal following a head-high bump on St Kilda's Hunter Clark, with the league stating he "carelessly engaged in rough conduct".
"There's been confusion everywhere," Damian Barrett said, explaining that the AFL tribunal has lost a connection with helping fans understand certain verdicts.
"I'm no clearer on what the tribunal will do."